The case against Arthur Leigh Allen was lacking physical evidence, but Toschi still couldn't let it go. He went for a second opinion on the handwriting and got some encouraging news. The second handwriting analyst shared a theory that a personality change could bring about other changes in a person, such as his handwriting.
But a theory based on conjecture wasn't enough to convict someone, so Toschi and his team obtained a search warrant to scour Allen's trailer.
The police officers found enough evidence that should have hypothetically nailed Allen. He owned the same windbreaker as one found at the scene. His shoe and glove size matched the Zodiac's sizes. He had a gun. Allen was in the area when one of the murders occurred. He fit the profile perfectly, yet somehow the second handwriting sample, ballistics and the prints in his trailer did not match the Zodiac's. Toschi, like others involved in the investigation, had become obsessed with the idea of Allen being the Zodiac.
So he was shocked and devastated to learn there wasn't an ounce of physical evidence pointing to the fact that Allen was the killer. Toschi even admits that he's not sure if he actually thought it was Allen or just wanted it to be him. Fear and uncertainty had overtaken his hometown. As shown with Robert Graysmith Gyllenhaal , some people were too scared to ever let their children out of their sight. Toschi just wanted this to be over.
Some events may have been slightly exaggerated for the sake of the film, but ultimately the events of Zodiac went down the same way they did in real life. Arthur Leigh Allen was a prime suspect for years with heavy circumstantial evidence against him. Just when it seemed like the police might have a break in the case, Allen died unexpectedly of natural causes.
On paper, Allen was a perfect match for the Zodiac Killer. But the physical evidence simply wasn't there, meaning that it could not have been him. Interrogation Assignment This documentary showcases a number of police interrogations that are problematic. The one that I believe is the most egregious is the interrogation of twelve year old Thomas Cogdell in the murder of his little sister, Kaylee.
His entire interrogation was one big violation of his constitutional rights, not to mention it verged on psychological torture. Allen was then serving a year prison term for a sexual assault in Green Bay that occurred after the attack on Beernsten.
In , with support from Beernsten and Avery, the Wisconsin Department of Justice implemented a model eyewitness identification procedure. Jay had several inconsistencies, some are major, and some, perhaps minor. The ones that stands out the most are appalling, such as the fact that he openingly stated to police and jury that he will lie avoiding criminal punishment.
During interviews, the majority of the answers received from witnesses did not add up or make sense. Also, individuals involved with the case claim they either did not recall what transpired or said something completely different from their previous statement. The above statement proves that the human memory is imperfect and cannot be reliable. According to the corners report there were many different lacerations and including the dilation of her anal cavity; it was concluded they had been done much later after her death occurred.
But the only one that was arrested was a young man by the name Red Manley; he was a year-old married man who was very intensely investigated even was showed off in front of the media while he was in handcuffs at that time. Later on he was cleared of all suspicion of the murder due to passing numerous amounts of lie detector tests, but there are some theories. The legal issue as discussed above is related to whether there is enough physical evidence to say that Scott Peterson is the murderer.
His behavior, the fact that he had an affair with Amber Fray shortly before his wife 's disappearance that he continued to do so after her disappearance, and that he lied multiple times, and his going to the Berkley Marina on the day of his wife 's disappearance while the bodies of the victims were found not too far from that location, make him a very likely suspect. However, there is still not direct evidence of him committing the murder so there is an issue as to accusing someone of murder and sentencing him to death with this kind of evidence, is it enough and would this be just?
Moreover, the state of California considers an 8 weeks old or older fetus as a victim. The Zodiac killer was a serial murderer in the San Francisco area during the nineteen-sixties. He was known for the letters he sent to the San Francisco police.
The letters included various enciphered messages, which lead to police being wildly confused as they spent days upon days trying to decipher the Zodiacs cyphers. Some of his earlier cyphers were easily solved, others remain unsolved to this day. While the Zodiac Killer was never caught, many suspects came to light during the time of the investigation. Being the former boyfriend of Darlene Ferrin and a Zodiac Killer survivor, he is shown a lineup of photographs and asked if any of the men pictured attempted to kill him 22 years prior.
Last time I saw this face was July 4, Furthermore, a partial DNA profile was run from a sample required from a Zodiac Killer envelope in , and Allen could not be ruled out as a suspect.
The San Francisco shut down their Zodiac Killer investigation in , but as of the release of the film it remained an open case in Napa County, Solano County, and Vallejo. That being said, there is no figure in the story who has more fingers pointed at him than Arthur Leigh Allen. First there are the harmonious pieces of circumstantial evidence. The first possible incident involving the murderer in Vallejo, California happened eight months after Allen was fired from his job because of child molestations.
Two days after his meeting with Toschi, Armstrong, and Mulanax he moved to a different county, and letters stopped coming in for three years. As noted by Robert Greysmith, it was only after police moved away from Allen as a suspect that the letters began again — and then the letters noticeably stopped once more after Allen was arrested and sent to prison.
Four years passed, but after Allen was released in , the letters started again. Altogether the evidence pointing at Arthur Leigh Allen seems solid — but there are some key holes in the case.
0コメント